Voyage Charters. Freight. Shipowner is entitled to receive freight according to the quantity which he’s delivered.

… The shipowner will be entitled to full freight if he is ready to deliver in substance at the port of destination the goods loaded, though in a damaged condition
Dakin v Oxley (1864) 15 CBNS 646.

Part Delivery

If only part of the goods is arrived at the final destination, the shipowner is entitled to receive freight according to the quantity per ton which he has delivered, while the consignee in case of part delivery has a remedy of action against the owner. Even if the goods arrive damaged it will not necessarily deprive the shipowner from his right to freight. A test stated in Dakin v Oxley (1864) 15 CBNS 646 by Willes CJ contemplates that the cargo arrived must meet requirements of both forms of identity, i.e. in quantity and in quality, for the shipowner to be entitled to freight. If quantity delivered to destination is so small and worthless, then the question would arise whether practically speaking any part of the cargo has arrived.

When goods arrived in full but physically damaged then it must be ascertained whether they arrived in specie. If it is so changed in its nature by the perils of the sea as to become an unmerchantable thing, which no buyer would buy or honest seller would sell, then there is a total loss and, therefore, no freight is payable.

The test above prevents the charterer or cargo owner to claim that freight had been forfeited when damage, however trifling, was caused to the cargo during transportation, follow the rule that each party hears the damage resulting from his own breach of contract, and no more. Thus, any damage caused to the cargo is the subject of a cross-action, and did not affect the right to the freight.

Share this article on:

Readers’ comments:

Posted by:   

Be first to comment …
Leave your questions and comments here

Although author encourages visitors to leave their comments using this form, but if you unable or unwilling to use it for any reason you can forward your mail to to contact with him.